Where to Find the Best Pizza in Southern Maine (Straight from a Local)
If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Southern Maine, you’re asking the right people — it’s the first thing every guest wants to know within a day of checking in. And every time, we send them to the same place: Seacoast Pizza and Pasta in Wells.
It’s not fancy. It’s not trying to be. It’s just really, really good pizza, made by people who clearly care about it, in a spot that feels like the kind of place a local would actually take you.
What to Order
Here’s the honest truth: you can’t go wrong on the menu, but if you want our personal picks —
- My go-to: The White Tomato Basil. No red sauce, just fresh mozzarella, thin tomato slices, and basil on a perfectly crisp crust. It’s light enough for a summer night but still feels like a real treat.
- My daughter’s go-to: The Meat Lovers. If you’re feeding a crowd (or just really hungry after a beach day), this one delivers — loaded, hearty, exactly what it promises.
Order one of each and split it. That’s usually how it goes at our table.
Good to Know Before You Go
- Outdoor seating in summer — grab a table outside and make it part of the evening, not just a takeout stop.
- Open year-round, with the exception of January when they take their well-earned break.
- Full menu and hours are on their site: seacoastpizzapasta.com
Our Pick for Best Pizza in Southern Maine
Southern Maine has no shortage of pizza spots, but if you ask us, this is the best pizza in Southern Maine — the one we keep coming back to and the one we keep sending guests to. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice between beach trips or settling in outside for a real dinner, it’s a solid bet.
Now it’s your turn. Comment below with links to YOUR favorite pizza stops!!! Photos too, if you’ve got them — because apparently we’re the kind of people who stop mid-bite to photograph a slice before eating it. No shame. The pizza waited. It survived.
Enjoy your stay — and save room for a second slice.
